Is Christianity more like communism or capitalism?


That’s the question asked by a recent study in America. Here’s one unsurprising finding for you:

Income seemed to influence the survey. 46 percent of people with incomes of $100,000 a year or more believe that capitalism is consistent with Christianity, while only 23 percent of those with incomes of $30,000 or less said so.

No kidding.

On the other side of the coin Dan Partridge admits,

“There are elements of Communism that resonate in my heart and mind. I like the emphases on social justice, one people working towards a common goal, and, to an extent, the idea that we share an inherent value and dignity which is expressed in different abilities and vocations.”

But there’s a problem,

“Communism throws everybody into the mixing bowl and imparts an ideology of same-ness, but it’s a same-ness which is average, mediocre. Christianity is so much better.”

So for a different perspective turn to a different source. How about Randy Alcorn and his new book Managing God’s Money. In this review the book is described like this:

This is no-holds-barred stuff; he teaches that most of us have neglected our responsibility to give deeply, consistently and generously. He rebukes the materialism that inhabits the church to almost the same extent that it inhabits the world. He calls for a radical rethinking of the way most of us relate to our money.

A timely word then to a world that needs to rediscover fresh, generous and liberating ways of living with money. And Tim Challies offers some more thoughts on how to resist the consumer mindset that is so prevalent in capitalist societies.


Discover more from The Simple Pastor

Enjoyed this? Subscribe to The Simple Pastor to get the latest posts sent to your email.

4 responses

  1. Agreed with the emphasis on generosity, but to go anywhere near answering the question raised, we need to have a theological view on (a) the nature of society (b) the role of the state and (c) the nature of ownership.

    In your own time, in between packing…

  2. Ian M Reed avatar
    Ian M Reed

    I grew up in the West of Scotland where it would be inconceivable for a Christian to be anything other than a socialist. For the last 20 years I have lived in the affluent Southeast of England where to have ‘socialist’ tendencies was seen to be ‘unchristian’ and ‘communist’. For me, fortunately, I have retired and returned Scotland and have to say that I am still a Christian Socialist at heart. There is no doubt there is a connection between the type of cultural background and what people think concerning the question posed.

    At a diffent tangent, I have often posed the question – ‘which is more dangerous for a Christian – to live under Communism or Capitalism?’
    My own belief is that Christians tend to thrive under the godless oppression of Communism whereas they tend to become weak and ineffective under Capitalism. Many a believer in the Southeast rather heatedly disagreed with me – I wonder why?

    1. Hi Ian, that’s a very interesting perspective and I’m sure culture does make a difference. I’d be intrigued to know more about what kind of Christianity thrives under communism and what kind fails under capitalism and see where the overlaps and differences are. Thanks for commenting.

  3. Firenationwarrior avatar
    Firenationwarrior

    Christianity is like Communism in that, if you worship Jesus, he’ll give you eternal life and if you don’t, you get eternal death.  No matter how pure or heroic you are, if you just don’t love Jesus, he’ll throw you in Hell!

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Discover more from The Simple Pastor

Subscribe now to keep reading and get access to the full archive.

Continue reading